Rule of Law Radio Archive Search Engine

If you find the site useful and want to help me keep
it updated and working, please consider donating

Listing search results for single subject


So since every single chapter, whether at the original date of enactment or later expanded, is limited to the single subject of transportation, then nothing in this code can be applied to any activity that is not transportation.

So not only is it limited to a single subject for that bill, then you have subsection B,

Remember that single subject thing we talked about at the beginning?

In the title or caption, the legislation is limited to a single subject matter subject.

single subject originally enacted, it's void. Under every state constitution I'm aware of,

If you're not, does Wyoming have a single subject requirement for bills that are being legislated upon?

Is there a clause in the Wyoming Constitution that says the legislature must specify what single subject the bill they are writing encompasses?

Here in Texas, they're limited to a single subject for any legislative bill.

and the single subject requirement versus the original title of the bill enacted by the legislature

No, transportation is not defined in the code. Okay. And the original enactment or the current enactment, if it's a reenactment or recodification enactment of the statutes, Wyoming has a single subject clause, right?

Yes. So, in the original legislative bill, what does the caption say, the single subject that all the statutes relating to pickups falls under?

I just used the pickup as an example so you could say, hey, pickups related to this single subject according to the legislature, that single subject is transportation.

Same thing. It falls under the umbrella of whatever single subject the legislature declared covers all of them.

single subject declared by the legislature in the original bill from

constitution I've read there is a single subject requirement for every single

I went with Dr. Graves' plan of the single subject and verb kind of stuff, and keeping

It's called the Single Subject Clause here in Texas we've got one.

Nor can you amend it over time to remove the requirement that it be limited to that single subject and thus be applied to something that is not transportation.

of the legislature in putting the subject matter, the single subject matter in the title of a bill

But they're also the ones that subvert the original single subject requirement of the law.

They are trying to alter the purpose of the definition to affect something that is outside of the single subject requirement.

which is the sole single subject of which the entire code applies. Period.

That is now completely disassociated from the single subject requirement and the single subject matter that the legislature said the transportation code was meant to regulate and govern.

they're all under one single subject you need to find it Tyler appreciate your time Eddie

fact that the single subject matter clause of the Texas Constitution under Article III,

Not only Article 3, Section 35 case law that says exactly what the single subject clause

It's called the single subject provision.

And that single subject is itself the actual subject matter that the individual court must have jurisdiction over in order to prosecute the case to begin with.

Okay, here in Texas it's easy because it says the single subject that all those

So, look up single subject clause and my island constitution and look up an emergency clause.

should have everything dealing with the single subject and everything the legislature is

Because the Ohio Constitutes, you contain a single subject matter clause requirement

But if it is not being used for the purpose regulated by that single subject matter requirement

where that single subject matter clause at the very top of the bill tells you that everything

in this bill must relate to this single subject, and if that single subject does not apply,

single subject matter is that that legislation had to apply to, and it cannot apply to anything

Once again, prove positive that even in prior history, the single subject always was relating

That's the single subject that is listed in the caption section,

Now, even though they can enact 500 sections under 14 chapters and six titles, all at the same time, every single one of them must deal with that one single subject alone.

Not when there is a single subject requirement in the Constitution.

So they couldn't enact them in one bill if your state has a single subject clause requirement,

What is the single subject that was used to enact the entire title or code that relates

But in either case, it remains the same, there has to be a bill with a caption or title heading that enumerates the specific single subject that every single title and chapter of that code is limited to.

I don't know of any state that does not have a single subject clause provision.

and collectively put them under a single subject and thus increase the amount of legislation

Here in Texas, they changed transportation objects to be under the single subject of transportation.

that legislation must express the single subject of which it applies in its title, according

Okay, so when you find the original bill, it will tell you what the single subject is

It is a complete violation of the single subject clause.

The officer that I talked with kept going back to the legal terms within the less than deadly sin. I made the point that those are just objects under the single subject but of course they don't even understand the constitutional restrictions or limitations of the single subject clause.

I talked to a couple of law librarians out here about trying to find the single subject clause from the legislative bill and they just get this blank look on their face and there's not much help there.

We should be looking at the 1960s for the single subject clause.

Well, knowing what the single subject clause is and how it applies to the law can help provided you can show that they're using it or created a law that deals with more than one subject in violation of that reference in the Constitution.

said what transportation means in the state of texas what the single subject matter clause of

becomes what is the single subject requirement of the government code if it relates solely to

government then according to that single subject requirement government is the only one that can

relating to the single subject matter clause requirements for any bill enacted by the legislature

law as meaning something else, or where there is a single subject clause requirement.

Transportation is the specific subject matter the single subject matter that is constitutionally mandated for every piece of legislation other than appropriation bills

You get that? Even though they are both crimes you can't put the elements of shoplifting under murder and still call it murder and you can't do that and still comply with article 3 section 35 of the Texas Constitution which requires a single subject for a piece of legislation

You get it? And in this case that single subject was murder and over here the single subject was transportation

mandate that every legislative act must have a single subject which all the statutes in

In SB 971 back in 1995, transportation is the single subject matter under which all the statutes of that code were enacted.

As the single subject matter, another legal phrase for that term is subject matter jurisdiction.

The single subject matter that controls the application of that code.

It is the single subject matter that the code itself is limited to according to the actual

And I'm, Arizona Constitution has a single subject matter clause in the legislative section, but unlike you guys in Texas where you have that pretty strong language that a bill cannot,

It specifically prohibits them from enacting any law outside of a single subject matter with multiple subjects in it. It specifically prohibits them from delegating that authority to anybody else by specifying exactly who gets it in the first place, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

The issue here is whether or not your state constitution requires all legislative bills to have a single subject statement on them in its caption.

The enrolled bill will have that caption, which will and should contain that single subject that that set of laws is applicable to and must be constrained to.

From the 1950s, 1930s when they enacted that here, there is no single subject clause that specifically says that this is for transportation.

that because transportation is the single subject matter under which motor vehicle and

word signifying the single subject in the title of the enrolled bill SB 971. They didn't

What we need to do is get a record for judgment on how transportation is defined, what it actually means, and that it cannot be ignored as an element because it is the single subject under which everything else in that code resides.

It is the single subject the legislature tied every single statute in the code to.

On what the term transportation means in relation to the transportation code and SB 971 is the bill in acting that code where the title specifically says transportation is the single subject to which all the statutes in that code are tied.

in its entirety specifically says that transportation is the single subject matter for all of those

subject of the legislation. Hence, it is the single subject of the entire code. Therefore,

now i have the three victories which is good let me ask you a question raider does the oregon constitution have a single subject matter requirement for legislation

what is the title of the bill what does it say the subject matter is that that bill relates to if the constitution has a single subject matter requirement then the bill has to tell you what that single subject matter is

or that it's it's normally called in a many states it's called the motor vehicle code not just vehicle code the motor vehicle code okay here in texas it happens to be called the transportation code which is specifically titled to match the single subject that the bill itself relates to

i did see that yes yes sir does it deal with signage does it deal with building roads and all this other kind of stuff if it does then and there's a single subject requirement then this cannot be the single subject of vehicle code

now the thing you're going to have to have to prove that is first and foremost like i was telling truth raider you need to look at whether or not pennsylvania's got a single subject matter clause in its constitution which i'm sure it does

that's a different provision than the fact that the original legislation must contain a statement of what that single subject is within its caption or title whatever pennsylvania calls it that's why you need a copy of the original bill

there was an original recodification that collected all of those statutes dealing with that single subject under the title of that single subject and into one bill and that bill is the one that's going to save your butt if it comes up and says that this is all transportation

completely ignoring the single subject context that the Constitution requires

object versus single subject context of the statutes allowed them to hide a lot

violate the single subject clause of the constitution of the state would it not

problem it can't be general if there's a single subject clause requirement in the state constitution

the law as a whole and everything boils down to what constitutes a single subject a carrier has

3 section 35 the single subject matter clause and then they've ignored the

implementation of that single subject matter clause within the title of the

Since the primary single subject matter jurisdiction in context of the transportation code is specific to transportation,

that was being used to transport persons or property upon the highway specifically for the single subject matter purpose of transportation.

The statute within the transportation code and the contextually limiting legislatively declared single subject matter transportation cannot be legally ignored by the courts.

my constitutional single subject matter limitation argument regarding the correct legal meaning

Do you need a certified copy of the single subject clause?

The single subject clause, you need a certified copy of the actual bill or not the whole bill,

The single subject that governs this is transportation, which y'all know I've also been telling you

still not exclude them from the umbrella of the legislative single subject matter that

Single subject clause question.

Is that the single subject clause?

We no longer are operating within the single subject matter clause.

under the single subject matter context of, in this case, transportation within the Texas

Well, that's not true, because the Texas Constitution says that the word in the title of the act that describes the single subject matter

a heading on every paragraph and then keep your paragraph to a single subject matching

Is the single subject matter that makes those terms actually mean something

When the single subject that those actions must operate under is overall the commercial fishing or in this case the transportation of person's goods or property for compensation or hire

Well, before you even get to properly you have to be able to show what the single subject matter is those statutes are limited to

See here in Texas we have a single subject matter clause in the Texas Constitution that says any legislation

Must identify the single subject of which every part of that legislation applies

Specifically says in its caption that the subject matter, the single subject that all the statutes of this recodification pertain to is transportation

And it is that they are attempting to separate the statutes from the single subject matter that governs those statutes

Everything within that statute must be read and interpreted in compliance not only with the Constitution but with the single subject matter specifically stated in the title of the bill that created it

And then again, the Transportation Code itself limits that authority of implementation to the single subject matter stated in the caption of the bill

And the implementation is limited to what the single subject matter the legislature defines for that implementation actually is

Why? Because it would violate the single subject matter clause.

The second rule is that all reading and interpretation of the statutes is to be strictly limited to the single subject matter the legislature placed the statutory scheme within.

This means the statutes within this single subject matter do properly apply to oranges, grapefruits, lemons, limes, pineapples, and any other citrus fruits.

However, the second meaning and interpretation of the single subject matter limitation wording suffers from an ambiguity problem, which is, does the term green refer to the color of the fruit on the outside or the inside or both?

The reason being that they are two distinctly different single subject matter classes, as number one deals with the state of a fruit's actual ripeness, and number two deals only with some aspect of its particular physical color, irrespective of its ripeness.

Therefore, to try and read and apply them to both together would run afoul of the single subject matter requirement provision of Texas Constitution Article III, Section 35.

But the statutory terminology actually has a very different and exclusive meaning and use only within the single subject matter context of the statutes themselves.

they have expanded the use of the statute outside of the scope of its subject matter, and thus they have violated the single subject matter clause just as surely as if they had gone back and changed the single subject matter from transportation to motor vehicles.

The statute was following the single subject rule. It was just for useful operators. And apparently in the statute, they snuck in some language that said that you also need to have a driver's license.

It was being driven for the purpose of whatever the single subject matter clause is, which

For the purposes of our discussion, that hard candy shell is the single subject clause of

The single subject requirement that everything in that bill must pertain to, or it's not

That statute's unconstitutional because it violates a single subject clause.

Okay, now besides the single subject matter, there is another problem with how they conduct

of the intent, as long as the text does not violate the single subject matter provision

Search the archive

Dave Champion Search

Find topics, phrases, and exact timestamps across Dave Champion transcripts.

Open Search →
DaveChampionSearch
Search the archive

David Knight Search

Search transcripts and jump directly to exact moments in the David Knight Show.

Open Search →
DavidKnightSearch